Search Lincoln Cannon Menu
Lincoln Cannon

Thanks for visiting!

A Dialogue of Faith with Jesus and Socrates

4 December 2023

Listen to recording

Epistemic Atonement

In an ancient grove, Jesus and Socrates sit across from each other, embraced by olive trees and bathed in golden light from the slowly setting sun. Socrates’ gaze is penetrating. Jesus’ regard is peaceful. They begin to converse.

Science and Faith

Socrates: Greetings, Jesus. I have heard much about your teachings and the faith you inspire. It seems to me that Christianity, your way, is deeply rooted in faith, while future times will find their foundation in science. How do you reconcile these seemingly divergent paths?

Jesus: Socrates, it is good to speak with you. While it is true that Christianity is often perceived through the lens of faith, in contrast to the lens of science, they are not as separate as they appear. Science, much like faith, requires a form of trust. Think of it as trust in the principles of non-contradiction, the uniformity of space and time, and causality.

Socrates: Intriguing assertion, Jesus. You suggest that science, which prides itself on empirical evidence and rational analysis, operates on a form of faith? Is this trust not different from the faith you advocate, one that often transcends empirical understanding?

Jesus: The faith I speak of is not a blind leap into the unknown, Socrates, nor an abandonment of reason. Rather, it is a recognition of the limits of human knowledge. We, as finite beings, cannot answer every question, nor can we fully comprehend the vastness of the universe. This faith is a practical necessity, a way to navigate the unknown while seeking greater understanding.

Socrates: So, if I understand correctly, you propose that both life and scientific endeavor inherently involve faith, for we often act without absolute certainty or complete knowledge. Science, like religion, must start from certain basic assumptions that cannot be empirically proven?

Jesus: Precisely. In science, principles such as causality and the uniformity of the universe are foundational, yet they are not empirically proven. They are assumed. This is a form of faith. Empirical evidence has its limits, and even in logical systems, there are axioms and methods that we must accept without proof.

Socrates: It is a compelling point, Jesus. The reliance on unproven assumptions in science does mirror the faith you speak of in religion. But does this not lead us to a perplexing dilemma? If both science and faith are built on unproven premises, how do we discern truth and navigate our lives effectively?

Jesus: The key, Socrates, lies in understanding that faith is not the abandonment of reason or inquiry, but rather a component of our continuous search for truth. We must embrace our limitations and strive to expand our knowledge and understanding, always open to learning and growing.

The Nature of Faith

Socrates: Jesus, you make a compelling case for the existence of faith within the scientific method. However, let us delve deeper into the nature of faith itself. Isn’t faith often equated with blind trust or adherence to dogma without question?

Jesus: Socrates, faith is frequently misunderstood in that manner. Yet, in its true essence, faith is not merely blind trust or unthinking adherence to dogma. Rather, it is a response to the inherent limitations of human knowledge. We cannot have answers to all questions, and thus, at times, we must act without complete knowledge. This is where faith becomes a practical necessity, guiding us through the unknown.

Socrates: So, you propose that faith is an integral part of both life and scientific endeavor. Are you suggesting that we operate in faith regularly, making decisions and forming beliefs based on incomplete knowledge?

Jesus: Exactly, Socrates. In life, just as in science, we are often in situations where absolute answers are not available. In these moments, faith guides us. It is a principle that enables us to act, to decide, and to continue our search for understanding and truth.

Socrates: Interesting. So faith, in your view, is not an abandonment of reason but a complement to it, a means to navigate the gray areas of our understanding.

Jesus: Precisely, Socrates. Faith complements reason, filling the gaps where evidence and knowledge are not yet complete. It encourages us to explore, to inquire, and to learn, despite our limitations.

Logic and Faith

Socrates: Jesus, let us now consider the role of logic. First, for context, you’ve observed that science relies on certain premises, like causality and uniformity, which are not empirically proven but merely assumed. And you relate this with the faith you advocate.

Jesus: Indeed, Socrates, science does rely on such premises. Causality, uniformity, and other basic assumptions underpin scientific inquiry. They are not empirically proven; they are foundational to the very structure of scientific reasoning. In this sense, science requires a form of faith – a trust in these fundamental principles, despite the lack of empirical proof.

Socrates: This suggests a limitation on empirical evidence. What about non-empirical matters like logic? Are they different? Or are we to understand that logic, too, operates within a context of that which is unproven?

Jesus: Precisely. Logic, much like science, is built upon certain axioms and methods that are taken as given. For instance, the principle of non-contradiction is a foundational aspect of most logical systems, yet it is not something proven within the system – it is assumed. This, too, is an act of faith, as I define it: a trust in something not fully proven but necessary for progress and understanding.

Socrates: It seems, then, that both science and logic, pillars of rational thought, rest upon unproven assumptions. Does this not suggest a sort of faith at the heart of rationality itself?

Jesus: Indeed, it does, Socrates. This form of faith is not blind or irrational; it is a practical and necessary component of rational inquiry. Without such foundational assumptions, the pursuit of knowledge, whether through science or logic, would be impossible.

Socrates: Then, is it fair to say that faith, as you describe it, is not just a religious concept, but a fundamental aspect of our quest for knowledge and understanding?

Jesus: Yes, Socrates. Faith is not confined to religious belief but is an integral part of our intellectual and existential journey. It is the trust we place in the basic principles that guide our exploration of the world and our quest for truth.

Objectivism and Faith

Socrates: We have acknowledged that science and logic rest on unproven assumptions, akin to a form of faith. Now, let us consider Objectivism’s claim against faith. It proclaims independence and rationality, opposing blind faith and dogma. Yet, ironically, some say it falls into the trap of dogmatism. Do you not find, Jesus, that this highlights the fallibility of human systems and the need for a more critical approach, which continually questions and learns from errors?

Jesus: Socrates, the failure of Objectivism to uphold its own standards of critical thinking and independence indeed underscores a profound truth. Humanity, in pursuit of knowledge and truth, often becomes entangled in its own dogmas. This is where Pancritical Rationalism becomes valuable, advocating for constant inquiry and the acceptance of our fallibility. It is an approach that aligns with my teachings of humility and continuous seeking of truth. However, this does not negate the need for faith. Rather, it complements it by acknowledging our limitations and striving to overcome them.

Socrates: So, you suggest that Pancritical Rationalism, with its continuous open-ended inquiry and learning from errors, requires a form of faith itself? A faith in the process of seeking truth and acknowledging our fallibility?

Jesus: Precisely, Socrates. Pancritical Rationalism is a method of acknowledging our epistemological limits while continuously striving to expand them. It recognizes that our understanding is never complete, and that there is always more to learn. This continuous journey of seeking truth, of admitting that we may be wrong and striving to get closer to the truth, is an act of faith. It is faith in the power of inquiry, in the growth that comes from acknowledging our errors, and in the unending pursuit of knowledge.

Socrates: If we accept that Pancritical Rationalism requires faith in the process of inquiry and learning, does it not also imply faith in the underlying meaning of our pursuits? That our continuous search for knowledge is not just an endless void, but a journey towards something meaningful?

Jesus: Indeed, it does, Socrates. In every act of seeking, in every question we ask, and in every error we learn from, we are expressing faith in the meaningfulness of our pursuit. The acknowledgment of our fallibility and the continuous search for truth are acts of faith in a universe where knowledge and understanding are valuable and attainable. It is a reflection of the belief that our endeavors, our striving for knowledge and wisdom, have profound significance.

Socrates: So, Jesus, you propose that faith and rational inquiry are not opposing forces, but rather complementary aspects of our quest for understanding and meaning?

Jesus: Yes, Socrates. Faith and reason, belief and inquiry, they are not adversaries. They are partners in our journey towards understanding ourselves and the world around us. Faith motivates us to seek, to question, to learn, and to grow, while reason guides our steps in this journey. Together, they form the foundation upon which we build our understanding of the universe and our place within it.

Pragmatism and Faith

Socrates: Let us now consider Pragmatism, Jesus. This philosophical approach acknowledges practical limits to inquiry and the necessity of action. It seems to me that genuine creativity and innovation often stem from acting in the absence of complete knowledge. Does this not suggest that faith, particularly blind faith, has a creative power in itself?

Jesus: Socrates, you rightly perceive that Pragmatism addresses the limits of human understanding and action. However, I would argue that faith, as I advocate, is not blind but is a conscious choice made in the face of uncertainty. This faith, or trust, propels us into action even when we lack complete knowledge. It is not a leap into the dark but a step towards the light, guided by trust in the goodness and meaningfulness of our endeavors.

Socrates: But if one acts without complete understanding, is this not a form of blindness? How can one be certain that their actions, guided by faith, lead to desirable outcomes?

Jesus: Certainty is not the realm of humanity, Socrates. We act with faith precisely because we are not certain. However, this faith is not without reason or experience. It is a reasoned trust, informed by our understanding and our experiences. When we talk about faith in a religious context, it should be about trusting in the values and principles that have stood the test of time. Just as Pragmatism suggests, we often must act before achieving complete understanding, but these actions are guided by a faith that is both informed and rational.

Socrates: Then, are you suggesting that faith, in its true form, is an acknowledgment of our limitations, a recognition of the necessity to act despite incomplete knowledge?

Jesus: Precisely. Faith acknowledges our limitations and yet encourages us to strive beyond them. It is a recognition of the unknown and an embrace of the journey towards understanding. Faith is a principle of action and power. It is the force that drives us to explore, to question, to grow, and to contribute to the betterment of ourselves and our world. True faith is dynamic, leading to exploration and discovery, rather than stagnation.

Socrates: But if faith is dynamic and leads to exploration, how does it differ from the rational inquiry you earlier agreed was essential?

Jesus: Faith and rational inquiry are two sides of the same coin, Socrates. Rational inquiry generates understanding. Faith moves us when rational inquiry has yet to provide answers. It gives us the courage to act when reason alone is insufficient. Faith is the bridge between what we know and what we aspire to understand. It is the driving force behind our quest for knowledge and meaning, complementing and enhancing our rational endeavors.

Socrates: So, in your view, faith is not in opposition to reason, but rather works in concert with it, propelling us towards action and deeper understanding?

Jesus: Exactly, Socrates. Faith and reason are partners in the human quest for truth and meaning. While reason helps us navigate the world of knowns, faith guides us through the realms of unknowns. Together, they form a harmonious relationship that leads to a fuller understanding of ourselves and the universe.

Fallibility and Truth

Socrates: Jesus, we have discussed the intersection of faith and reason, but now let us explore the concept of fallibility. The recognition of our limitations and the effort to overcome them can be seen as a form of faith, can it not? In this context, how do you perceive the continuous effort to question, seek answers, and improve our understanding?

Jesus: Indeed, Socrates. Acknowledging our fallibility and striving to surpass it is an act of faith. It is faith in the human capacity to grow and evolve. In my teachings, I have always encouraged seeking, knocking, and asking – a pursuit for truth and understanding. This journey is never-ending, for as humans, our understanding is always incomplete. But it is the pursuit itself, fueled by faith in something greater, that is valuable. Faith is not about having all the answers, but about seeking them tirelessly, trusting in the process of growth and enlightenment.

Socrates: But if we are always to question, always to doubt, is there ever a point where we can say we know something? How do we balance this endless inquiry with the necessity to act on what we know or believe we know?

Jesus: Socrates, it is about holding our beliefs with a sense of humility and openness. We can act on our current understanding while remaining open to new insights and revelations. Faith is not static; it is dynamic and evolving. It allows us to act with conviction, yet with the readiness to adapt and change as we learn and grow. It is this balance – between action based on current understanding and openness to new knowledge – that is key.

Socrates: This seems to imply that knowledge and understanding are always in flux, always subject to change and revision. Is there no bedrock of certainty?

Jesus: The bedrock, Socrates, is not found in unchanging knowledge, but in the enduring values that guide our search for truth. Courage, compassion, creation – these are constants that remain even as our understanding of the world evolves. They are the guiding stars in our quest for knowledge. Our faith is anchored not in the infallibility of our knowledge, but in the steadfastness of these guiding principles.

Socrates: So, you propose that it is in the values we hold and the direction they give to our search for truth where we find constancy, rather than in the content of our knowledge itself?

Jesus: Precisely, Socrates. It is in the values that underpin our search for truth where we find the constancy that human hearts seek. Our knowledge will evolve, our understanding will deepen, but the values that drive our pursuit of truth and our actions based on that pursuit remain constant. In this way, faith is a commitment to these values, a trust in the journey towards ever-deepening understanding, guided by these enduring principles.

Defining “Faith”

Socrates: Jesus, we have delved into the concept of faith in various contexts. However, I am intrigued by the way you define “faith.” It appears to be a dynamic, action-oriented principle, rather than blind or irrational. Can you elaborate on this definition of “faith” in a religious context?

Jesus: Certainly, Socrates. In my teachings, faith is not a blind acceptance of doctrines or an unexamined adherence to tradition. Instead, it is a living principle of action, a power that moves us towards compassion, understanding, and creation. Faith is trust in something greater than ourselves, not despite reason, but in harmony with it. It is an active engagement with the world, a commitment to seek, to serve, and to love.

Socrates: But how can faith be both a principle of action and a virtue of belief? Is there not a tension here?

Jesus: The tension you perceive, Socrates, comes from a misunderstanding of faith. Faith is not contrary to reason; rather, it complements it. Faith moves where reason has yet to tread. It propels us forward when evidence is scarce, guiding our actions with hope and love. It is trust in the unseen, belief in potential, commitment to act for the betterment of humanity and the world. Faith is courage to act, even in uncertainty, guided by the highest virtues of compassion and creation.

Socrates: This sounds like a faith that is continuously evolving, one that does not stagnate in dogma. But then, how do you ensure that this evolving faith does not lead astray, into paths of error or harm?

Jesus: Faith, guided by love and compassion, always seeks the good. It is tempered by humility and openness to learning and growth. It does not claim to possess all answers but is always seeking, always growing. True faith is aware of its limitations and is open to correction and new understanding. It moves us to action, but always with a heart willing to learn and to be guided by love and truth.

Socrates: So, in your view, faith is a dynamic journey, not a static destination. It is a commitment to growth, learning, and action, underpinned by core values of love and compassion.

Jesus: Precisely, Socrates. Faith is a journey towards greater understanding, a path walked with the virtues of compassion and creation as our guides. It is a commitment to act in the world, to make a difference, guided by the light of these enduring principles. Faith is the bridge between what is and what can be, driven by the hope and trust in a better world. It is a powerful force for good, an active agent of change and growth.

Faith Crisis

Socrates: Jesus, your depiction of faith as dynamic and action-oriented is compelling. However, does this account not also suggest a personal crisis, a moment of nihilism where one must choose faith in the face of meaninglessness? How does one overcome such a crisis?

Jesus: Indeed, Socrates. Every soul encounters moments of doubt and existential questioning. In my own experience, faith is not merely a solution to these crises but also a product of them. It is during these moments of profound questioning that one realizes the necessity of faith, not as a blind leap into darkness, but as a trust in the possibility of a meaningful world shared with others.

Socrates: But this trust in a shared world, how does one arrive at it amidst the chaos of uncertainty and the void of nihilism?

Jesus: It begins with a deep introspection of one’s desires and wills. In my lowest moments, I did not desire a world devoid of meaning, so I chose to trust in the possibility of a world rich in meaning. This is not a passive acceptance but an active will to share in the creation of a meaningful existence. This faith, therefore, becomes a bridge between the individual and the community, between personal will and collective meaning.

Socrates: So, you suggest that one’s personal crisis can lead to a form of faith that is both reconciliatory and communal?

Jesus: Precisely. I often associate this with the concept of atonement – a reconciliation not just within oneself but also with others and the world at large. It is a continuous, active engagement in shaping a world that aligns with our shared values of courage, compassion, and creation. This faith is not static but ever-evolving, a response to our ongoing encounters with life’s complexities.

Socrates: But Jesus, how does this faith differ from the arbitrary choices of dogmatism? How does it not lead one to follow, without question, the whims of authority, emotion, or popular consensus?

Jesus: Faith, as I advocate, is not an abandonment of critical thought. It is a commitment to align one’s actions with a higher principle – love. It does not blindly follow authority but questions and seeks understanding. It recognizes the shared human experience and strives for harmony between personal desires and the greater good. This faith is not in conflict with reason; rather, it is an acknowledgment of our limitations and an effort to transcend them through love and reconciliation.

Socrates: Then, this faith is an embrace of our fallibility, a constant striving for betterment, and an acceptance of our shared human condition?

Jesus: Yes, Socrates. It is in our nature to seek, to question, and to grow. Faith is an acknowledgment of our journey, an affirmation of our shared pursuit of truth and meaning. It is a testament to our resilience and our capacity to find hope and purpose amidst life’s uncertainties.

Pancritical Rationalism and Faith

Socrates: Jesus, let us return to Pancritical Rationalism. This philosophy suggests that nothing needs to be taken on faith, as all is subject to unceasing criticism and reevaluation. How does this reconcile with your views on faith and meaning?

Jesus: Socrates, Pancritical Rationalism indeed advocates for continuous inquiry and learning from error, which I support. However, even in this endless cycle of criticism and reassessment, there lies an implicit faith – faith in the very concept of shared meaning.

Socrates: Are you suggesting that even Pancritical Rationalism, which denies the need for faith, actually operates on a form of faith?

Jesus: Precisely, Socrates. For any critical or rational endeavor to occur, there must be a fundamental belief in the existence of meaning, a shared understanding that makes communication and critique possible. This belief in shared meaning is a form of faith, albeit not commonly recognized.

Socrates: But if meaning itself is contingent upon a form of faith, does this not weaken the stance of Pancritical Rationalism, which aims to operate without assumptions?

Jesus: It does not weaken it, Socrates, but rather illuminates a fundamental aspect of human existence. Our desire for meaning, our pursuit of understanding, and our engagement in dialogue all stem from a fundamental belief in the possibility of shared understanding. This is where faith and reason converge – in our shared pursuit of knowledge and meaning.

Socrates: Yet, Pancritical Rationalism seems to suggest that we can, and should, question everything. How does this align with the necessity of faith in meaning?

Jesus: Pancritical Rationalism correctly advocates for questioning and reevaluating our beliefs and assumptions. However, even in our deepest skepticism, we operate under the assumption that our inquiries have meaning and that our dialogue leads to greater understanding. This underlying assumption, this faith in the coherence and significance of our endeavors, is what enables the very process of critical rationalism.

Socrates: So, you assert that faith, in this context, is not a suspension of critical thinking but a foundational element that enables it?

Jesus: Indeed, Socrates. Faith in meaning is what drives our pursuit of knowledge. It is what motivates us to engage in critical thinking and rational discourse. Without this faith, our efforts would be devoid of purpose and direction.

Socrates: This perspective seems to bridge the gap between faith and reason, suggesting that they are not opposing forces but complementary aspects of our quest for understanding.

Jesus: That is so, Socrates. Faith and reason, when properly understood, work hand in hand. Faith provides the foundation upon which reason builds. It is the trust in our collective endeavor to seek truth and understanding that propels us forward in our journey of inquiry and discovery.

Knowledge and Faith

Socrates: Jesus, as we conclude, I reflect on our discourse. Your advocacy for faith, even in the light of Pancritical Rationalism, presents a compelling harmony between belief and inquiry. How do you characterize the interplay between knowledge and faith?

Jesus: Socrates, knowledge, in its essence, is neither inherently good nor evil. It is a tool, a beacon that illuminates our path. But the direction we choose to walk, enlightened by this knowledge, is guided by faith. Faith not just in what we know, but in what we hope for – the prospect of a life that embraces courage, compassion, and genuine creativity.

Socrates: So you propose that faith is not an antithesis to knowledge but rather an enabler, a force that propels us to use our knowledge judiciously?

Jesus: Precisely. Faith bridges the gap between our current state and our potential. It drives us to explore, to question, and to grow, while also reminding us of humility in our fallibility. In this journey, faith and knowledge become partners, each informing and enhancing the other.

Socrates: But, Jesus, how do we mitigate the risk of knowledge leading us astray, towards paths of destruction or nihilism?

Jesus: This is where the true essence of faith comes into play, Socrates. Faith is not merely a trust in knowledge or capability; it is a trust in the goodness and potential of humanity. It is a belief in a meaningful world where our actions, guided by knowledge, are tempered with love, empathy, and a deep sense of responsibility towards each other and our world.

Socrates: So, in essence, faith is a compass that ensures our pursuit of knowledge is aligned with the greater good?

Jesus: Indeed, Socrates. Faith ensures that our quest for understanding uplifts, rather than diminishes, the value of life. It is a reminder that in our pursuit of knowledge, we must not lose sight of the virtues that make us truly human – courage, compassion, and a relentless drive towards a harmonious creation.

Socrates: And in this light, faith is not a blind adherence to dogma but a conscious choice towards a life of purpose and positive creation?

Jesus: Yes, Socrates. Faith is about making choices – choices that reflect our deepest values and aspirations. It’s about embracing the unknown with the hope and conviction that our actions can lead to a better world. It’s a commitment to continuous exploration, not just of the world around us, but also of the vast landscapes within us.

Socrates: Your words, Jesus, provide a profound perspective on the role of faith in the human experience. It seems that faith, far from being an obsolete relic of the past, is a vital and dynamic force that shapes our journey towards knowledge and understanding.

Jesus: And so, Socrates, let us continue to seek knowledge, not as an end in itself, but as a means to enrich and elevate our existence. Let us harness the power of faith to guide this pursuit, ensuring that our journey is not just one of intellectual growth, but also of moral and spiritual elevation – esthetic exaltation.

Thanks for reading! If you've found value here and would like to support my work, you can do that in at least five ways:

  1. Comment Thoughtfully Below
  2. Share on Social Media
  3. Subscribe to My Newsletter
  4. Make a Donation
  5. Check Out My Sponsors!

Article Sponsors

Thrivous is the human enhancement company. We develop nootropics to enhance cognition and geroprotectors to promote healthy aging. Use code SUPERHUMAN for 50% off your first order at thrivous.com.

Comments